Smith's Rosebud Salve

Recently I've bought the Rosebud Salve in both the tin and the tube and here's my piece of opinion of these products.

The tubes I bought in Canada for 7 Canadian Dollars at Sephora and I bought the Original and the Strawberry. The Original smells like rose and the Strawberry smells like strawberry, in conclusion both smell really nice. However the formula in the tube is waxy and thick but it comes off really easy, I feel like I have to keep reapplying...

The tin I bought in the US at Sephora for $7 US Dollars. It smells the same as the Original tube. Goes on thin, it stays on longer. The downside is that it can get messy during application.